When an aging parent is diagnosed with dementia of any kind, it can be devastating and confusing to the family. For some, there is denial: “It’s not that bad, I don’t see anything wrong with her, and let’s just let things stay the same for now.” For others, there is overreacting and trying to push the aging parent into a care facility before that may be needed, just because of assumptions about dementia. Family fights over these things, such as we address at AgingParents.com, are not unusual. As the disease affects each person in an individual way, it is impossible to generalize much about what decisions a person with dementia can make.
How much choice does an aging parent with dementia have?
However, as enshrined in the law, it is useful to allow self-determination as much as is safe and reasonable. Generally, self-determination is considered to be a basic human right. When a person’s decision-making capacity is impaired by disease, the question of what is safe and reasonable is often the subject of heated debate among family members. Is it reasonable to do whatever the elder says he or she wants because she says she wants it? Or is that merely pretending that the individual is not impaired and allowing the elder to put one’s self in danger that the elder cannot appreciate?
An example is the case of Bonnie, an 85-year-old woman who lost her husband of 58 years. The house she and her husband had lived in was in need of much deferred maintenance. She had memory problems, was deeply grieving and severely depressed. Her three daughters would have been wise to meet and make decisions together. None lived in the same state as their mom. All were capable of helping. But conferring together was not how this family worked. Historic conflicts surfaced. The eldest daughter, Morgan, decided to appoint herself to be in charge and forged ahead, moving her mom out of her home and sending her from place to place while she used mom’s money to fix up the house. She then put her mother in an assisted living facility in a state where Bonnie knew no one. Morgan said she would visit sometimes as she had a vacation home near the facility. Morgan then promptly went back to her primary residence in her home state, leaving Bonnie there by herself. This enraged the other two siblings.
Bonnie, who is hearing impaired for phone calls but could text, reached out to her second daughter, Marian, and begged her several times to come and get her out of there. Marian then jumped in her car and drove many hours to the facility. She packed up her mom and took her back home to Marian’s house. A family standoff ensued. Morgan was furious. After removing Bonnie from her own home, she had taken Bonnie to a doctor who said Bonnie had dementia and that she could not make financial decisions. That much was not in dispute. But did Bonnie have the right to decide where she was going to live and whom she wanted to have at her side, helping as needed? Morgan did not think so and she controlled everything. Bonnie was very upset with Morgan about this.
We met Marian and Bonnie in person at AgingParents.com, where we invited Morgan and the other sister to join the conversation by teleconference. Morgan refused. We urged Marian to have Bonnie evaluated by a neurologist find out more about the extent of her dementia-related impairments. And at AgingParents.com, Dr. Davis, geriatric psychologist, did a series of tests. The results were surprising. Bonnie tested better than expected, now that she is much less stressed and further along in the process of grieving. In the comfort of Marian’s home she said she felt very secure. She wanted to stay, rather than go back to her own home alone, and she wanted Marian and her husband to keep helping her.
This is case illustrates the effort by Marian to honor her mother’s right to self-determination in choosing where she wants to live and whom she wants to help her with managing her finances. It also illustrates the effort by Morgan to remove her right to self-determination by forcing her into assisted living when she preferred to live with family. There is no doubt that Bonnie is safe in Marian’s home where help is available and can be supplemented with home care as needed. Bonnie may not be able to keep track of her checkbook, but she is very clear about her preferences.
- If your aging parent is diagnosed with dementia, it doesn’t necessarily mean that the parent is incapable of making ANY decisions. Finances are likely to need management by someone else but the right to make decisions about where to live must be looked at separately.
- Not every person with dementia should live alone and not everyone needs a care facility either. Options within families should be discussed jointly, and with the aging parent’s right to some self-determination in mind. Eventually a person with dementia cannot live alone but the point when living alone becomes unsafe is very individual.
- The concept of self-determination is complicated when it is considered for persons with dementia. Judgment gets impaired. Reasoning falls apart at some point. Safety must be the overriding concern but deciding what is safe works best when all family members look at the expressed wishes of their elder, together with current medical information.
- Grief, stress, moving to a different location, depression and other factors can significantly affect what a doctor sees in examining a person for dementia. Repeat and updated evaluations are essential in deciding what is best for any aging parent with a diagnosis of dementia.
If you have an aging loved one with dementia and are facing complex decisions about their safety and well-being, we can help. Reach out to us at AgingParents.com for our nurse-lawyer, psychologist consulting services.
Carolyn Rosenblatt, RN, Attorney, AgingParents.com